Advertisement
MP Husnee speaks in parliament. (Photo/Parliament)

JSC doesn't require criminal standard of evidence to remove judges, says Husnee

Parliament approved the removal of the two justices on 14 May 2025 following allegations that they had attempted to influence a court order.

40 minutes ago

Judicial Service Commission (JSC) President and Manadhoo MP Husnee Mubarik has said the commission assesses allegations of judicial misconduct under the civil standard of proof and is not required to establish sufficient evidence for criminal prosecution before recommending the removal of a judge.

Speaking during Tuesday's parliamentary sitting, Husnee defended the JSC's procedures following criticism over the dismissal of former Supreme Court justices Dr Azmiralda Zahir and Mahaz Ali Zahir.

Parliament approved the removal of the two justices on 14 May 2025 following allegations that they had attempted to influence a court order.

However, the Prosecutor General's Office decided on 10 September 2026 that there was insufficient evidence to prosecute the former justices, following a request from the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) to pursue charges.

Husnee made his remarks in response to comments by Vaikaradhoo MP Hussain Ziyad (Fitte) during the parliamentary debate on the government's proposed defamation bill.

Ziyad criticised the removal of the two justices, describing the process as improper.

He argued that the decision not to prosecute them had left their reputations damaged despite the absence of criminal charges.

Responding to the criticism, Husnee said the JSC had consistently applied the civil standard of proof when investigating judicial misconduct and determining whether disciplinary action, including dismissal, was warranted.

He said the same standard had been applied during the previous Maldivian Democratic Party (MDP) administration.

Husnee noted that judges had also been removed from office during the previous administration and that some cases, including those involving Supreme Court justices, had subsequently been referred for criminal investigation.

He questioned how many of those investigations had resulted in criminal prosecutions.

"Of those judges, how many were prosecuted following the completion of criminal investigations? How many of the Supreme Court justices who were removed faced criminal charges?" Husnee asked.

He said the absence of criminal charges did not mean that the JSC had acted improperly in recommending the removal of judges.

According to Husnee, the commission determines whether a judge should be removed after assessing allegations of misconduct under the civil standard of proof and following the applicable procedures.

"Under no circumstances is it necessary to conduct a criminal investigation and establish sufficient evidence for criminal prosecution before taking such action. Neither the Constitution nor the law requires it," he said.

The controversy surrounding the removal of Azmiralda and Mahaz began on 26 February 2025, when the JSC suspended three Supreme Court justices as the court was preparing to hear an application for an interim order concerning constitutional amendments.

The amendments introduced additional circumstances under which members of Parliament could lose their seats, including provisions relating to changes in political party membership.

An application had been filed seeking to suspend the implementation of those provisions until the Supreme Court concluded its consideration of the matter.

A hearing on the interim order was scheduled for 11am on 26 February, after a notice was issued at approximately 9pm the previous evening.

At around 1am on 26 February, an unidentified individual submitted a complaint to the ACC concerning three Supreme Court justices.

Shortly before 10am, ACC President Adam Shamil sent a letter to the JSC concerning the matter.

The JSC subsequently notified its members of an emergency meeting scheduled for 10.30am.

The commission decided to suspend the three justices while preparations were under way for the Supreme Court hearing.

Those suspended were Dr Azmiralda Zahir, Mahaz Ali Zahir and Husnu Suood.

Suood subsequently resigned from the Supreme Court, while Azmiralda and Mahaz were removed from office following parliamentary approval on 14 May 2025.

The Prosecutor General's subsequent decision not to pursue criminal charges against Azmiralda and Mahaz has renewed debate over the evidentiary standards applied in judicial disciplinary proceedings and the circumstances under which judges may be removed from office.

Comments

profile-image-placeholder